Converge and Coalesce have released their 1996 live show at the defunct legendary NYC venue CBGBs. That raw recording at the influential venue has newly been issued on digital and vinyl formats, with proceeds from it set to go towards the family of late concert promoter/visual artist Rich Hall. In a joint statement, the two influential metalcore outfits offered:
“This is a tribute to our friend Rich Hall, who introduced our bands to New York City in the early days. We will never forget the profound impact he had on all of us in the underground music community.”
Hall passed away in January of this year, with this GoFundMe having been launched by his family.
“Live At CBGBs” track listing:
01 – Converge – “Forsaken”
02 – Converge – “Dead”
03 – Converge – “For You”
04 – Converge – “Antithesis”
05 – Converge – “Color Me Blood Red”
06 – Converge – “The Saddest Day”
07 – Coalesce – “A Safe Place”
08 – Coalesce – “Cut To Length”
09 – Coalesce – “Grain Of Salt”
10 – Coalesce – “Blend As Well”
11 – Coalesce – “Harvest Of Maturity”
12 – Coalesce – “73c”
13 – Coalesce – “This Is The Last”
14 – Coalesce – “Simulcast”
You can find digital copies via the below Bandcamp embed, while vinyl can be pre-ordered through deathwishinc.com with an August 08th release date planned. Speaking of the effort and his fallen friend, Converge vocalist Jacob Bannon offered:
“This Saturday, we are scheduled to celebrate the life and legacy of Rich Hall through a show in Brooklyn NY.
In the early to mid-1990s, the metallic hardcore subgenre— at least as we know it today— was just beginning to take shape. Our bands were raw, chaotic, and hard to grasp without seeing them live. The sound didn’t fit easily into existing scenes, and as a result, we were often overlooked by press, labels, and promoters. Out of necessity, we carved out our own spaces: basements, rented halls, wherever we could gather. And in these hidden corners, new scenes quietly began to grow. While bands were active in the Tri-State area, New York City itself remained a challenging place for our subgenre to break into.
Rich Hall changed that.
A young fanatic of all things heavy, Rich took a chance on us. As a promoter, he welcomed this new wave of chaotic, metallic hardcore into the city, bringing our bands into venues that had once felt out of reach. With enthusiasm, warmth, and unwavering support, he carried the torch of NYC’s legendary underground— places like CBGBs— into a new era.
It didn’t take long for Rich to become more than just another promoter. He became a friend, a part of the fabric of the community we all loved so deeply.
Over time, our paths diverged, as they often do. But I never stopped keeping tabs on Rich. I watched from afar as he built a beautiful family and found his voice as a visual artist. When I heard about his passing, it hit hard. He was walking a bright path, and he deserved more time here. My thoughts turned to our memories, his family, and the challenges they would now face without him.
To process my own feelings, I turned to something familiar— work.
While digging through an old storage bin, I came across a stack of cassettes. Sitting right on top was one in particular, it felt as if the universe placed it there to be seen. It was a copy of our first show at CBGBs on November 17, 1996— Converge on one side, Coalesce on the other. That show was one of my first real interactions with Rich. For me, it symbolized something much larger than music. It marked the beginning of so much that I hold dear— things that would never have been possible without him.
I hoped the recording was still intact enough to release in tribute to Rich and his family.
I quickly reached out to Sean Ingram of Coalesce, explaining my finding and intention, and he excitedly gave his full support for the project. Shortly after, I sent the tape to Zach at GodCity to be digitized. Weeks later, we got word that it had been successfully salvaged. The next step was sending it to Brad Boatright at Audiosiege for mastering. Once the audio was finalized, I worked with Pol from Branca Studio to design the release. His artwork perfectly captured the spirit I envisioned.
The recording itself is chaotically raw and unfiltered— two bands in their most primordial form. Since no video footage exists, the listener must use imagination to color the intensity of the scene that winter day.
Together, Converge and Coalesce are releasing the recording as a tribute to Rich Hall–Our friend and supporter who helped bring our music to New York City in the earliest days. His impact on the underground music community was profound and we will never forget him and what he did for us.
Proceeds from this project will be donated to the Hall family in perpetuity.”
The tribute shows mentioned above for Hall include the following lineups.
June 13th, Brooklyn, NY – Warsaw:
From Autumn To Ashes
Orange 9mm
Harvest
Kiss It Goodbye
Skycamefalling
Dystaron
June 14th, Brooklyn, NY – Brooklyn Monarch:
Converge
Cave In
Deadguy
Defeater
Today Is The Day
Shutdown
Ensign
Nora
Cipher
Locked In A Vacancy
Fashion Week
