Underoath’s Spencer Chamberlain: “You Can Only Play Hardcore Or Heavy Metal For So Long”
Underoath vocalist Spencer Chamberlain was interviewed by Altpress.com regarding the bands decision to call it quits and his future plans.
On deciding to end the band:
“…A lot of it has to do with family. I think it’s time. I don’t know if that sounds weird or not. Underoath were a part of something important that happened, as far as heavy music goes and the underground scene goes. I think we did our part and now it’s out of our hands: It has been out of our hands for a while.
I feel like that scene still exists, but we don’t know anything about it anymore, you know? We’ve grown up a lot, and it was just time for all of us. I’ve been in the band for a decade. Chris [Dudley, synth op] and Tim [McTague, guitarist] for close to 15 years. It’s been a long time in people’s lives.”
On the limitations of writing for Underoath:
…It’s tough because we wanted to keep going and changing, but we couldn’t. I’d be tracking a song and be like “Man, I have to scream because I have to because that’s what Underoath ‘is’.” I would just want to sing the whole song, because I think it would be better and then we’d end up going back and forth and coming off somewhere in between.
There was another step to be made with Underoath, but I don’t think the fans would have been happy. That’s always a weird feeling to know you’re getting better, but Underoath have to be a heavy band—you have to be that. That’s what side projects are for; because you have to be that and that was maybe a part of some of the guys not wanting to tour so much—because they can’t do that anymore. You can only play hardcore or heavy metal for so long.”
On his own future plans:
“I’ve only told one person this before, about two years ago. I’m a musician; I’m not just the guy who fronts Underoath. I’ve been playing piano and guitar my entire life. I’ve been singing since I was in elementary school. I played my first show when I was 12 years old.
I can’t leave behind the people that have followed anything I’ve done. I can’t leave the industry behind. It’s like working as a lawyer and your firm decides to shut down, you start your own firm or you can go join someone else. I’m not going to go join someone else’s band—that’s just not what I do. But I was coming home a lot and locking myself in rooms and studios and writing songs even when Underoath were not even close to breaking up.
Even talking about it, I was doing stuff. I never wanted to make the mistake that Aaron made and release something at the same time, because I think he could have gone way further with the Almost, but he had to do double duty with Underoath. I saw that happen and was like, “Dang, that sucks.” I feel bad, but this band happened first. It’s not fair for us to sit there while he tours with the other band, but that really did hurt that band. Not that they’re not doing well, but I feel like it was bad timing.
In my mind, I’m writing stuff I want to hear and I can’t do anything with. I’m already halfway done recording it. I have 30 songs—it’s different [sounding] and some of the fans will come with me, but some of them will probably be mad at me. I made that decision when I started writing songs.
I was like, “If I’m writing some style of music and it’s just not as good as my favorite band then I’m doing something wrong.” So, I took all of the elements from the things that I loved and sat down and decided to make something that I want to listen to.
I’ve got a lot of stuff to share with people and a lot of stuff to say. That’s as much detail as I’m going into—I am not stopping. There is another band and I’ll make that announcement when the time is right.”
The full feature can be read over at Altpress.com. The band will release a ‘best of’ effort titled “Anthology 1999-2003” on November 06th through Solid State. The compilation will feature two newly-recorded tracks.



COMMENTS
Makes sense. Kind of a damned if you do, damned if you don’t. I remember being upset when I saw them live after CoT came out and they said they would never play anything from Cries of the Past again. If they don’t want to be heavy and don’t want to sell out, move on. They’ve lasted a lot longer than most bands in that genre.
I never understood why going “softer” always equates to “selling out.” As long as a band is following their creative instincts and not forcing themselves into a certain style just to make a quick buck, they haven’t sold out. If anything, a heavy band no longer feeling “heavy” but doing it regardless would be the real sellouts.
All that said, Underoath sucks Jesus penis.
I didn’t mean that to come across as how I see it, but as how they would be perceived. I agree with what you typed. If the shoe fits, wear it. Unretrofied is one of my favorite DEP songs. Colony of Birchmen was the song that made me buy a Mastadon album.
“I’m not going to go join someone else’s band—that’s just not what I do.”
Except that’s exactly what you did with Underoath. I love this band, but don’t say stupid shit like that.
I was thinking the same thing. I mean, I like their albums in descending order and stop at Define the Great Line – so I don’t listen to anything that Spencer isn’t on – but come on, you can’t say a dumb line such as that….
This Runs Through. Anyone remember that?
Let’s be honest though; he meant way more to Underoath after one album then Dallas Green did after 3. It truly was a different band with the same name after he joined. A fresh start for an established band rarely comes, but twice is probably asking a bit much. I get what he’s saying in the context of how he’s saying it, though. And this is coming from someone who only liked They’re Only Chasing Safety and half of Define The Great Line.
I understand that, and started listening during the transition phase (same thing with KSE during the initial Jesse-out Howard-in days) and They’re Only Chasing Safety is without a doubt my favorite album of theirs – but I don’t think that is mostly due to the lead switch, but also as a result of the band getting older, maturing, and finding their spot in the market. With that being said, I’m a bigger fan of Dallas in Maylene than when he was in Underoath – but he’s older, wiser, etc. in Maylene (different styles aside).
Please never refer to your band as hardcore or heavy metal again there Spencer. Metalcore it is.
So you mean he can’t refer to his band of one of two genres, only the sub-genre formed from an amalgamation of the two genres? Holy genre Nazi, Batman.
Metalcore is a warn out genre that became it’s own thing. Deal with it. These guys helped start it up, or atleast keep it going. Some band’s got smart and decided to become awesome (Poison The Well).
Hardcore: Bane/Blacklisted
Heavy Metal: Sabbath/Slayer
Metalcore: Underoath/Norma Jean
Death Metal: Cannibal Corpse/Suffocation
There’s only a few genres that are what they are, and Metalcore is their genre. Don’t be butthurt about the truth.
Thanks for the genre lesson, I had no idea Black Sabbath was a metal band. My butt is no longer hurt, I have seen the light. You sound like one of those stereotypical dudes who likes Cattle Decapitation and thinks clean singing is “gay.”
You sound like one of those dudes that makes blind assumptions. I actually have enjoyed a few of UO albums. Nothing amazing to me, but they have never bothered me. I always felt Norma Jean was the better of the 2. My musical liking is very vast. Probably even more then yours, but that’s neither here nor there.
Wow, 99′-03′. Pretty lengthy carrer that merits an anthology. Pfft. This band was never good. I can’t remember if it was once or twice I went to see their openers and left before they played. Don’t care enough to remember. That is what I do.
Everyone is definitely entitled to their own opinion. I honestly used to hate this band, until I listened to ‘Define The Great Line’ all the way through. That album is what I call a solid album. From front to back, there isn’t one song that shouldn’t be a part of it. Great writing. I recommend you listen to it, my friend. I promise you will like it.
I believe it is intended to read 1999-2013…which IS in fact pretty lengthy.
Oh really dude? Your name fits how feel about that. They still stink like gym dick.
After Aaron left, they shoulda just changed the name to OVERoath.
newest cd is top 2 if not the best they have released
agreed. newest album may be the best one they’ve done.
as Ryan from poison the well once stated so well on going for a softer sound “being in a hardcore band is about doing whatever the fuck you want.” this is pussy lips fluttering.
Why do u think I work a 9-5 job making a real salary? I respect the hell out of this guy and what he does but come on. You’re not Metallica, Motley Crue, Deftones, Slipknot, System of a Down etc etc. You are not going to be able to pay the bills for the rest of your life on Underoath. I love music. I love playing music. It’s not reality and I think your decision was wise. You and so many other great bands have had the same outcome. It’s just not financially smart to carry on. If it was, Himsa would still be making music.
underoath is a career band you nutsack. comparing himsa to these guys is like comparing Moscow to New York City. get bent.
Oh God fucking damn, you just poked a wound that will never heal. Himsa is one of my faves, man. Still bummed to this day they split up. Fuck.
Xasafx…you analogy sucks. Any single Himsa album kicks more ass than the entire Underoath catalog, and I like Underoath.
100% truth my friend.
My personal favorite. This song destroys all.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EgjJeu1wVL8
Holy fuck, hell has frozen over. I fully agree with Wurst AND kturl. Wtf!??!!?! Himsa was one of the best bands of the last 10 years. Summon in Thunder is the best way they could have ended that band though.
Not to forget either, but Pettibone is a fucking hardcore legend. Undertow, amazing.
This paragraph “…It’s tough because we wanted to keep going and changing, but we couldn’t. I’d be tracking a song and be like “Man, I have to scream because I have to because that’s what Underoath ‘is’.” ” I don’t agree with. If you don’t want to scream, don’t scream, do something else.
I mean, look at the likes of Cave In and see how they have evolved over the years. I’m sorry, just because it is what is “expected” of you shouldn’t play a part in your decision to call it quitsville and if it is, you shouldn’t of stayed together for as long as you did.
Full disclosure: I quite like Underoath sans all the Jesusy stuff.
Agreed here, many bands change their sound to be what they want to be and still have plenty of success, sometimes more success then when they just did heavy music/screaming only. Look at Thrice? They went from playing some sort of punk-core amalgamation to becoming one my favorite chill out and put my feet up band. However, him not wanting to scream probably would not have went over well with the rest of the band, seeing as though their sound had gotten much darker and heavier with each release.
Aaron’s backing vocals were the big draw for me to this band, and i loved Chasing Safety through…well that last one with Aaron on it, name is eluding me right now. The most recent is certainly heavy, but is missing that bit of Aaron that kept me a fan.
Underoath failed for the simple reason that they didn’t really stand out. When bands like Lamb of God, Killswitch Engage, Unearth, Zao, As I Lay Dying were doing their thing, Underoath popped up with their sound among 20 other bands that sounded alike. Heavy, mellow, whatever, they just didn’t have that unique special something to keep them in the mix. They didn’t suck, but they weren’t amazing either. You had some good tracks, but I still can’t tell them apart from have the other emo-metalcore stuff. I hope they start other bands that do have a signature sound. I hope the individuals do well in whatever they choose next.
PS. Himsa!
I saw 18visions open for these guys in 03. Definitely stood out for the past 10 years.
Hanging up the coat after 15 years and 7 albums is generally not considered a failure.
Really? Chumbawumba has been around for 30 years, and released 17 albums, and if they quit tomorrow, they would still have a failed career.
UnderOath did their thing, and lots of people followed it, but they weren’t a major standout band. Probably 20 years from now not alot of people will be talking about them when reminiscing. I think alot of it had to do with their religious views. These don’t bother me, but they do alot of others. This band was more vocal about their beliefs then most.
They did not stand out…to you. Why do people assume their opinion transcends anything but themselves?
I used to really like this band but havent listened to their music in years. That said after reading this I wish I never would have listened to them in the first place if this was the mindset. You can only play “metal” “hardcore” for so long? You were neither and many bands have and continue to do so while staying relevant on top of it. Fucking pussy.
“Man, I have to scream because I have to because that’s what Underoath ‘is’.”
If you set yourself limitations, like you did with your band, then yes this is the case. If you progress and experiment, try new ideas, grow as musicians then you can do anything you want and the fans will respect you for that.
Just look at Cave In. You can always bring back the screaming.
The best example there is, changing styles totally but keeping their integrity.
Dude, “You can only play hardcore or heavy metal for so long.” What the fuck? The guy is 29 and converge has been around for what, 22 years? Stop fucking crying
Yeah, a total pussy comment. But what do you expect, the guy was never fit to scream.
His pussy comment to the side, have you really listened to DTGL or LITSOS all the way through? Spencer’s screams are actually pretty beastly. Ever since the guy took singing lessons he has been great. If anything, Aaron would get out of breathe and couldn’t sing for too long.
DUDE WAS PLAYING THE FUCKIN DRUMS AT THE TIME!!!
I know he was playing the drums. Obviously. And he’s an amazing drummer at that. It just makes for a frustrating listen (live) when the singer can’t really pull it off. I was just stating the fact that if you are going to complain about anyone not being fit to sing/scream or even question their abilities, I wouldn’t say it’s Spencer… I am actually one of the people on here who likes UO, so don’t take that little part of what I said the wrong way. It’s all in context man.
« Back View All Recent Comments »