Primus – Green Naugahyde
Prawn Song/ATO 2011
It’s almost ironic that on their first studio album in over a decade, Primus are still a musical anomaly. Admittedly the bands departure from the scene occurred on the back of perhaps their weakest album, 1999′s somewhat maligned “Antipop“; but that doesn’t mean that a new Primus album being in stores isn’t a cause for celebration alone, whether it ‘sucks’ or not.
Having spent the past decade in a state of on again/off again hiatus, their long-awaited return isn’t without casualties. For “Green Naugahyde” feels the absence of the bands most popular drummer, Tim “Herb” Alexander“–though that’s not to say it suffers from it.
His replacement, early-era Primus drummer Jay Lane, delivers an electrifying kit spanning performance in his stead. In fact, in many ways it feels like Lane‘s colorful and deep in the pocket playing keeps the group fluid and on task. Pushing them evermore towards a territory more akin to the sonic weirdness found on their full-length debut, “Frizzle Fry“.
Of course some will be worried about an invasion of the folky weirdness and perpetual meandering found on frontman/bassist Les Claypool‘s recent solo output. But thankfully they will have little to decry here. “Green Naugahyde” is flush with quirky irrelevance, slinky funk overtones and a chaotic mix of metallic bombast and jazzy chops. As if it needs to be said, it also features the trademark rubbery distorted bass-driven heroics that defined the band, with Claypool basking in all of his trademark kook.
Exceptional talent is exhibited from top to bottom. But what particularly makes “Green Naugahyde” stand out in the bands catalogue is the overall cohesiveness of its songwriting. There’s little reliance on overpowering effects or outlandish one-off instruments. What there is instead is oodles of intrinsic groove and dynamic interplay that could only have sprouted from organic jam room nurturing. A quality that shines through time and time again via the subtle rhythmic interactions and playful dynamics that repeatedly emerge.
That said, while certainly one of Primus‘ most focused and solidly written efforts; “Green Naugahyde” doesn’t necessarily possess a standout quirky ‘hit’ like so many of their past records. What it does have is an abundance of talented instrumental ability, peculiar timing and a wealth of sonic diversity. It won’t convert those not already in tune with the group’s eccentric output, even with a timely song (“Eyes Of The Squirrel“) deriding the inanity of pop culture.
But it will surely bring a smile (and possibly hand cramps) to any Primus fan who was worried that the group may have lost their spark or their way after such a prolonged absence from the spotlight.
Click the stars to rate this album.






COMMENTS
Man, I was really hoping the tagline stuck to the review. 4/5? I don’t care much for Primus. I thought there was finally someone who agreed! Guess not : /
I don’t care much for Primus myself but it doesn’t stop me from realizing what a brilliant band they are.
This is one of the stupidest things I’ve ever read. So, you clicked on this review, for a band that you don’t like, in the hopes that it would justify your opinion? How fucking small minded can you be?
Sixteen thumbs down
Excellent
c-c-c-combo breaker!!
Picked it up and haven’t stopped listening to it yet
Primus sucks!!!
agreed
got it yesterday, got my tickets about 2 weeks ago primus is the shit!
I have “hand cramps” already!
Let’s not put Antipop on the bottom of the heap now. That’s a fine ass album.
Same here. I’m still ignorant why exactly it’s felt as a lesser work. Eclectic Electric and the Final Voyage of Liquid Sky were great tunes.
Because Antipop belongs at the bottom!
Frizzle Fry
Pork Soda
Brown
Punchbowl
Cheese
Antipop
Haven’t listened to Green Naugahyde yet, but it’s sitting on my stereo. I imagine it somewhere between Cheese and Antipop though, judging by some of the reviews I’ve read. I’m not saying Antipop is a bad album, but it’s certainly the weakest. I’m not saying Cheese is weak, but it’s certainly not the finest work they’ve done that everybody seems to say it is.
ill never understand “joke bands” talented or not why should we take you seriously if you dont even take your own band seriously! i wish primus would stop making money and just go away cuz they’re giving me acid reflux
that is the dumbest thing, frank zappa was one of the most talented musicians of the band area, the techniques he used and the way he made music inspired so many people from rock to opera. Primus isnt a joke band anyway, they had a few joke type songs but the whole is more imporant then the sum. wbbb was not just a “beaver” reference it was a story wrapped up in a beaver referance.
It’s OK if you don’t get Primus. But you deserve a fucking truckload of acidic burning reflux!
constructing a good joke is very serious business.
that’s fine folks you can sail your seas of cheese and say its some complex story wrapped in an enigma and locked in pandora’s box which really just translates to a dipleasure for the government but when you strip it all down there is no story in what they write they are just lame and trying to write slapstick music is lame primus is a waste of time and musical effort and i hope to achieve more thumbsdown with this comment cuz in the end i dont listen to them im sad ive ever even been subjected to them and ive never given them any money so ive already won…………FACE!!!!
oh wow.. i didn’t realize… i fed a troll… sorry, everybody. :-/
Go easy on this guy. He likes Chimaira so it’s obvious he’s not all there.
Your punctuation is tip top…….
Why does the poll here not have anything that even resembles a positive vote towards Primus?
big primus fan eh?
Nah. I can take them or leave them. Just confusing why each option was unabashedly negative.
“Primus sucks!” is actually a positive vote.
http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Primus%20sucks
Ha me feel so dumbo. Well, at least I learned something today.
I have listened to it once so far and liked it. There is a sound void that only Primus can fill… When in the right mood, they are bloody amazing… but when not, they sound distracting somehow…
A good listen though, 3/5 – just because I wish they were a bit more melodic than weird.
I miss Tim Alexander. 3.5/5
Giving a 4 star for everything around here is kinda bogus.
I have to add this is an excellent review, minus the score.
Primus never disappoints me. Green Naugahyde is a fantastic album. I dont understand how people dont like it. I havent stopped listening to it, but I am a huge Primus fan. Its hard to name any band out there who can compete with Primus. The musicianship of the band is unmatched. Les plays that bass like its his bitch! LONG LIVE PRIMUS!!!
« Back View All Recent Comments »